The Fish House – Fort Myers Beach: A Beloved Waterfront Spot That’s Now Closed

For many years, the Fish House Restaurant was a well-known waterfront eatery in Fort Myers Beach, drawing locals, visitors, and boaters with its casual seafood fare, outdoor seating, marina views, and Gulf Coast vibe. Though it was part of a broader family of popular “Fish House” restaurants that included other Southwest Florida locations, the Fort Myers Beach outpost has now closed permanently and is no longer operating.

A Waterfront Favorite for Years

Located near the heart of Fort Myers Beach, the Fish House was long appreciated for its fish-house classics, generous portions, laid-back atmosphere, and scenic surroundings. At its Fort Myers Beach location, diners once enjoyed:

  • Fresh Gulf fish baskets, grouper sandwiches, and seafood platters

  • Fried favorites, shrimp, oysters, and casual coastal fare

  • Cold drinks and relaxed patio seating overlooking marina water views

  • Outdoor dining that tapped into Fort Myers Beach’s waterfront energy

It was a place where vacationers, fishing trips, and sunset cruises often culminated with a meal and a long drink while watching the tide roll in.

Patrons remembered the experience as casual and friendly, with menu highlights like smoked fish dip, crunchy hush puppies, stone crab claws, and local seafood combos. Even if some reviews varied, many people cherished the water-front setting and open-air feel that made it a classic beach stop.

Closure and Legacy

Today, the Fort Myers Beach Fish House is closed. The business has ended operations at this location, and the restaurant no longer serves customers. Multiple local listings note that the establishment is permanently shut, even though its address still appears in some directories as a former destination.

While the brand continues to live on through other Fish House restaurants elsewhere in Southwest Florida, the Fort Myers Beach chapter is now part of local history — remembered fondly by longtime locals and frequent visitors who once stopped here for fresh seafood by the water.

Where It Was Located

Fish House Restaurant – Fort Myers Beach (Former Address)
📍 320 Old San Carlos Boulevard
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

This spot sat within easy walking distance of the Matanzas Pass area and Fort Myers Beach’s main waterfront, making it a convenient dinner destination for beachgoers and town visitors alike.A Boater’s View: Marine Coordinates

For boaters revisiting the area or reminiscing about stops on local cruise routes, here’s an approximate reference point for where the restaurant once stood:

Approximate Marine Coordinates:
📍 26° 27.508′ N | 81° 57.140′ W

This coordinate situates you near the Fort Myers Beach waterfront and marina area where the Fish House once welcomed lunch and dinner crowds on the water’s edge.

What Replaced the Scene?

Since the restaurant’s closure, the Fort Myers Beach waterfront near the old Fish House continues to be a lively area with other dining and water recreation spots nearby. Visitors to the area will find:

  • Neighboring seafood restaurants and bars

  • Waterfront patios and marina views

  • Sunset-watching locations along San Carlos Boulevard

  • Paddleboarding, dolphin tours, and sunset boat excursions

The closure of The Fish House hasn’t stopped the community from thriving — it simply reshaped the dining landscape of this busy beach destination.

Remembering a Fort Myers Beach Classic

While the doors at this Fish House location have closed for good, many still remember it as a place where hearty seafood, bay views, and relaxed Florida energy intersected. Restaurants in this style — casual, centered on fresh Gulf catches and open-air seating — continue to define the Fort Myers Beach dining scene. And though this chapter has closed, the memories of dinners by the dock and breezy Gulf-side lunches remain part of the town’s culinary story.